Practical Magic, Supper Included
Something warm for dinner, chocolate cake for later, and a margarita whenever we please.
For our Practical Magic rewatch, we’re having the sort of supper that allows for a second helping without getting up for very long. A sandwich cut in halves. Cake already sliced. The evening belongs equally to a roomful of friends or one woman with possession of the remote.
First, something savory
Our choice is a sharp cheddar and apple toastie: sourdough, a little Dijon, thin slices of tart apple and enough cheddar to reach the edges. Butter the outside and cook in a skillet over medium-low heat until both sides are golden and the cheese has melted.
Put a few cornichons on the plate. Bring a proper napkin. It’s dinner, even if we’re eating it on the sofa.
Chocolate cake tonight and for breakfast.
The Owens household has a breakfast policy we’re happy to adopt.
Serve dark chocolate cake with a spoonful of crème fraîche tonight, then save a slice for the morning. We like it straight from the cake tin with strong coffee, preferably while still in our pajamas.
If friends are coming, wrap a slice so they can have breakfast chocolate cake as well. Buy it from a good bakery or make it ahead; either way, have it ready before pressing play.
About those margaritas
We’re keeping ours classic: tequila, fresh lime and orange liqueur, with salt along half the rim. Make one before the film, while the sandwich is cooking.
For an alcohol-free glass, stir fresh lime and orange juice with a little agave, top with sparkling water and use the same salted rim. Taste before adding more sweetness.
Settle in
Choose the seat with the best view of the screen. Leave a lamp on beside it, put the phone out of reach and bring everything over on a tray.
The Girl Dinner Edit
A platter for the sandwich halves. A glass that catches the firelight. We’re choosing pieces we’ll bring out again next Friday.
THE GOOD GLASSES
THE INVESTMENT · William Yeoward Corinne coupe — $85 each
Delicate vertical grooves and a slender stem. The sort of glass we’d happily collect two at a time. Gump’s lists this piece as final sale.
THE SCORE · Pre-owned Waterford Eileen — $19.99 each
Irish-made crystal from a discontinued pattern, with a cut foot and excellent condition guaranteed by Replacements. Finding a pair is part of the pleasure.
THE FIND · CB2 Eve coupe — $6.50 each on sale
A shorter stem, a generous bowl and enough texture to catch the candlelight. Equally inviting with our alcohol-free pour.
SOMETHING TO SERVE IT ON
THE INVESTMENT · Juliska Berry & Thread appetizer platter — $115
Whitewashed ceramic with a decorative border. We’re filling it with toastie halves and cornichons.
THE SCORE · Wedgwood Edme oval platter — $59.99 on sale
An English-made, discontinued serving piece, currently reduced from $79.95 at Replacements. A little cupboard treasure for our very informal supper.
THE FIND · Crate & Barrel Mercer platter — $34.95
White porcelain with a softly uneven rim. Room for supper tonight and pastries when someone stays over.
Prices and availability checked October 23, 2026, and subject to change.
